Re: Arie Gal on cbs news - STAR tax rebate
Posted 1/30/2017 7:27:28 PM by ave1024


Posted by DWKS810

Are you an attorney? Just curious.

There is a concept in contract law called "unconscionability". This basically means that even if a contract exists, the court should not enforce it if it is unconscionable - which means it is so unfairly skewed to benefit one side that it "shocks the conscience".





Well let me ask, are you an attorney? I am going to guess yes since you must be if you are asking me the question.

So as an attorney, where do you draw the line as to what is considered unconscionability? While I agree with your other points that this guy is obviously trying to dupe people into signing with him, the homeowners are signing with him to perform a service.

As I stated earlier, what makes this any different than somebody paying somebody to grieve taxes? Or mow my lawn? Or take my mail out of my mailbox and read it to me? Or answer my phone calls? Or get me my morning coffee and serve it to me in a spoon while fanning me with your other arm while I law down and watch Trump on TV?

Where do you draw the line regarding what do you consider a "service" and what is considered unconscionability? Nothing he has done is technically illegal. Good luck trying to prove unconscionability with this. Color me shocked if they manage to pull this one off. Schniderman is simply looking for good press. When is he due for re-election?

And to use your other example regarding selling organs. Selling organs doesn't fall under unconscionability. It falls under violation of the National Organ Transplant Act. It's illegal to sell organs.


Print Post      Close Window