|
Re: Arie Gal on cbs news - STAR tax rebate
Posted 1/30/2017 6:43:22 PM by DWKS810 Are you an attorney? Just curious. There is a concept in contract law called "unconscionability". This basically means that even if a contract exists, the court should not enforce it if it is unconscionable - which means it is so unfairly skewed to benefit one side that it "shocks the conscience". Basically, this guy created a scam where he duped people into signing these "contracts". He knew at the time that he sent out these mailings that people would think it was legitimate mail coming from the county, by making it look just "official" enough to fool them. His entire enterprise was built on taking advantage of people not realizing what they were entering into. The whole idea behind contractual agreements is that the two parties reach a bargain and enter into an agreement that suits both their purposes - yes, sometimes someone enters into a somewhat unbalanced bargain,and within reason that is their right, and their obligation to know what they are entering into to a degree. But when a contract is basically designed to victimize people - where the one party knows that no one in their right mind would enter into such an agreement, and it's basically relying on a degree of trickery, then that is not what a contract is meant to be. You are not supposed to be tricked into signing a contract. New homeowners get a deluge of mail and it appears most people mistakenly thought this was part of the free service offered... if SO many people fell for it that the AG's office got involved, then I believe there's a strong case for this being unconscionable. It's certainly what I believe, and it's provided for in the laws of our state. There are lots of contracts that can't be enforced for all kinds reasons. Contracts to donate your organs... contracts to adopt a child before they are actually born... you can't make a contract with someone that you will harm yourself if you lose a bet... just because you sign a contract does not mean it's automatically enforceable. |