Re: Cuomo free college announcement
Posted 1/9/2017 11:36:30 AM by eroxgirl


Posted by DiamondGirl


Posted by ohbaby08


Posted by DiamondGirl


Posted by ohbaby08

While I agree that $125k upstate is much different from $125k downstate, there has to be a cap. And there will always be someone just above the cap that doesn't qualify.

With that said, I'm shocked at how many people think $125k is such a small income, even on LI.



$125k in Long Island combined for two parents of the age to have an 18 yr old (meaning they have likely been working 20+ years at that point) is low. And no there does not NEED to be a cap, if my tax dollars and all the other people who earn over that amount are funding this then we should be able to benefit from it. In NYC there is universal Prek which my son attended--no cap. Public school k-12, no cap IMAGINE telling people they had to pay for k-12 bc they earned more than the cap amount? As it is our tax dollars fund it...



Of course there has to be a cap. The whole point of this program is to give kids who can't afford college the chance to go. You think someone who makes $1mil a year should get the same benefit as someone who makes $80k? That's insane. And comparing UPK or K-12 is not the same thing.



Why is it not the same thing? If you want to offer public education to citizens funded by tax payers then do that, the CAP on this program will further exclude the middle class citizens funding the program.



Its not the same because we are required by law to have a primary education, which is why public school is available.

We are not required by law to have a secondary education, but since we do not live in a caste system where you are expected to stay at the same station from birth through death, why is it so terrible to offer the poorest among us who also have the grades and intellectual ability an opportunity to receive that secondary education if they want it? They still have to do the work to get there and to stay there.

Financial aid is the only 'handout' that's truly fair IMO. If your grades drop you lose your financial aid. My cousin lost hers (as she deserved, because she was partying with her boyfriend and not going to class).

This will never actually pass anyway, but I can't get over how many people think it's grossly unfair to offer help to people who are less fortunate than they are, or how many people think the worst of mankind, automatically looking to the few who will try to cheat the system instead of the many who could benefit from it and in turn, become people who will contribute to society in a more positive and influential way than without an education.
Print Post      Close Window