Re: Making your child get a job
Posted 8/15/2016 11:03:03 PM by JennP


Posted by MandJZ


Posted by JennP


Posted by MandJZ

So I'm going to offer maybe a slightly different perspective? That said, you and your daughter made a deal and I think you should stick to it, 100%. However, I don't think I would make my kids get a job in high school, other than a summer job.

My job in HS, according to my parents, was to get good grades. If my grades fell and I didn't ask for help in a timely manner, I lost privileges and luxuries. I did babysit, but not regularly. I had summer jobs as a camp counselor from 16 on, but beyond that I didn't work as a kid. But that was my parents' decision and they had the means to do it.

I didn't get a car until I was in college and had a 4.0 GPA after freshman year. I volunteered and babysat in college a bit, but also still only had summer jobs. That was how my family did things - school, grades, education was the kids' job. But again - that's what worked for our family.

You need to do what's right for your family, and what feels right to you as a parent. In this case it does sound like you need a bit tough with her.



Edited bc I quoted the wrong poster.
*******************

I am going to respectfully disagree with this.

While every college is different, I do have a little bit of experience with the admissions process overall and what I have always understood is this: Unless a student is at an elite level in their sport or hobby, most schools are looking for accomplishment - or at least effort - in the volunteer/work area.

Of course schoolwork should come first - that should go without saying. However, there are ways to make sure a students' hours are limited. That's what working papers are for, after all. Additionally, while a job should be the first thing to go if grades slip, that doesn't mean the effort shouldn't be made to get one. A student can always quit if necessary - and lose the spending money as a consequence for not keeping up grades.

Having said that, I think if a teenager can't find a job, they should at least volunteer. When a child is 16, they need to find a job and start to become responsible for at least some extras - highlights, etc. - or give them up if necessary.

But overall, I think there aren't a lot of legitimate reasons for a teen 16 plus not to work. Yes, even during the school year. High school gets out early. Yes, it could be a lot to juggle especially with sports and activities, but it'll be worth it in several ways.



That's fair, as a general rule. However as I said we did what worked for our family. My HS did not get out early - I went to a Jewish school and I was at school from 8-4:30 every day, and the school was about 20-25 min from home so by the time I was home it was 5pm. Between dinner, homework for a double courseload, showering...that was it. I didn't hang out with friends on school nights. I didn't have time for anything else.

I very much respect families where kids get jobs in high school. I think it's fantastic and teaches valuable lessons. But I was sharing why in my family growing up it wasn't part of what we did, and if my kids attend a similar type of school I'm not sure I'd insist on them getting a job either.

That said - community service hours were mandatory at my school (more than triple the hours required by public schools) so I did volunteer during the year.



Understood - those are some late days for high school. I got out at 1:55!
Print Post      Close Window