Re: Is this rude?
Posted 7/21/2016 11:17:19 PM by JennP
Posted by chilltocam
Posted by LSP2005
I don't think it is Bs fault or obligation to take a new car into the city. A should have known the condition of her car and maintained it. Frankly, I would have suggested a train or an uber. But to me, if your car is in that bad of shape, I would have dropped it off and gotten a loaner car from the mechanic or dealer.
Things happen - cars break down unexpectedly. And you usually can't just drop in to the dealer and expect a loaner car to be available. I think that is kind of presumptuous to expect someone else to "maintain" their car - things happen
If I was B, I don't think I would have been to happy to take a car with no AC, but I probably also wouldn't have been thrilled to drive a new car into the city, but probably would have done it anyway. That, or if it was an option, I would have suggested taking the train. Do I think either of them was rude - no. Maybe a little annoying, but not rude. The car breaking down was not expected and things happen. Sometimes things are just out of your control
Agree with all of this.
Years ago my AC stopped working because the fan (I think) broke. It wasn't a new car but it wasn't super old either. Nothing else was wrong with it in the immediate aftermath - it was an isolated incident, not some slow decline.
Things happen without warning or notice so I don't think it should be held against Person A.
This really just sounds like it's an unfortunate incident that was no one's "fault."
|