Re: Moderation- warning long!
Posted 8/9/2006 8:49:54 PM by justthe4ofus


Posted by casey31

I feel like there has been a lot of discussion on this board and I wanted to post my thoughts on being a dog owner.

Dogs are vulnerable members of our world and as humans we owe it to them to care for them and give them good lives. We have hurt their species so much with cruelty and abandonment and it is awful how many dogs are in shelters.

IMO there is no breeder that is a good breeder. Dogs should NOT be bred at ALL until every older mutt is adopted from a shelter. The only justifiable exception is breeding guide dogs for the blind.

That being said, as an owner of two dogs I would never give them up because I didn't have time for them or because they were ruining my furniture. I would make time or look into training for issues like that.

However, there are justifiable reasons for giving your pet away to another good family (not a shelter). I feel strongly that if you feel your child is unsafe living in the home with the dog it is totally fine to find a good, new home for your dog with another family. Training a dog is not fool-proof and an injured child is horrible. If there is any doubt in the owner's mind then everyone, including the dog would be happier in a new child-free home. Also, if the owner discovers they have severe allergies. We got Tally last fall from a rescue organization and we had Casey for years before that. I was fine with Casey but when we brought Tally home my allergies were severe. I was hysterical because I had already fallen in love with her sweet personality but I had to be able to breathe at night. I shaved both dogs and got a $300 air purifier. My Dr. said that two dogs just overwhelmed my immune system. Anyway, we tried everything and luckily it worked. My system adjusted. But, if it didn't I don't think I would be considered a "bad" owner if I found another home for her. Wouldn't it be better for everyone involved if she could be with someone who could hug her?

Anyway, I believe that you need to think things through before getting a dog, it is a huge responsibility. But, I believe that there are some reasons where it is okay to find another family for your dog to live with. Additionally, when someone posts that they have no time it could also be they have things in their lives going on that we don't know about: illness, etc. Maybe if their lives are so chaotic it might be better for the dog to live with a calmer family- just a thought. If your life gets out of whack and you find a new loving family for your dog I think that is more responsible to the canine species then adopting a puppy from a breeder- even a "good" breeder. JMO.



I agree with you 100000000000% Growing up I had 3 dogs 2 were adopted from shelters (a pure bred sheppard and a pure bred dobbie), the third was from a woman standing outside the supermarket giving away pups (She was according to the woman a malamute retriever mix) Ok the 3rd was a little insane, not in a bad way. But the dobbie and the sheppard were the most AMAZING pets you could ever ask for. They were so good with my brother and myself. My brother was so rough with the dobbie and he NEVER EVER bit or snapped. She was amazing! The sheppard actually protected a child in the neighborhood from another aggressive dog not from the neighborhood. The mutt was obsessed with men with beards and was a fence jumper. All 3 were adopted and all 3 were great pets! When my husband and I decide that we have the time to give to a dog (and we will NOT get one until our daughter is old enough to treat her right and we have the time to give to the dog) we will definitely be adopting!!! To me I will have saved a life and that is great!
Print Post      Close Window