Re: Moderation- warning long!
Posted 8/9/2006 4:51:08 PM by casey31
Posted by MsMBV
I agree with 90% of what you said, and yes there are indeed times when giving up a pet is necessary, and no, it should not be to a shelter.
There are reasons to go to a responsible/good breeder, and that is when there are specific traits or characteristics about a breed that you want or want to avoid. A shelter or rescue org cannot 100% guarantee the lineage of a dog, and therefore cannot verify for a potential owner what traits may present themselves later. For example, a friend of mine wanted a dog his whole life, so when he bought his house he decided once he finished all the repairs he would get a dog. He read about different breeds & decided he wanted either a beagle or a KCC spaniel. He went to NSAL to look at a beagle that had been brought there that same day. He was given a chance to meet the dog, take him for a walk & all. When he went to go and give the donation fee & tell them that he would be back after work to pick up *snoopy* they told him no, we do not hold dogs, you need to take him now. Since he was on his lunch break he could not. Needless to say when he went back after work *snoopy* was already adopted out to another person. They then showed him a terrier mix. They convinced him that it would have the same temperament as a beagle (which is a ridiculous claim anyway). After thinking about it he took the dog, and that dog grew into a huge PIT BULL. Now he was inexperienced and would have never knowingly adopted a Pit as he knew he was not able to train properly. Well 2 weeks before the dogs 1st birthday he was forced to surrender the dog to be put to sleep, because he had bitten his mother. He went to a great breeder and has a lovely KCC Spaniel.
ETA: Especially for people who have children or plan to have children in the dogs lifetime, I think you need to know with 100% certainty what temperament your dog is inclined to have. JMHO.
Very good point about using a breeder and knowing more about the dog's temperment. I guess my point is this though: I feel like I would rather see a person go to a shelter and get a dog (after preparing their home and really committing to pet ownership) and then it not working out- and then having to return the dog to the shelter, or even better, finding a home that is a better fit (ex: no kids). I would rather see that then a person going to a breeder to get a special breed for it's temperment. When you go to a shelter you have at least a 50% chance of it working out. When you go to a breeder you are bringing another dog into an already overpopulated world.
edited for spelling
Also edited to say: We adopted Tally from a rescue - she is 2 or 3, noone knows. Even the vet cannot say what her breed is. Probably some mix of cattle/herding breeds. Yes, we got lucky that her temperment is very sweet and my DH handles dogs very well. But, if iit turned out that we decided she would be too aggressive for our home with a baby I think we better serviced the canine species by finding her another home then if we had gone to a breeder to get a specific "type" of temperment. We took a chance on her and it worked and we rescued a dog. If it didn't we still would've worked our butts off to find her another home. In the end, Tally was saved either way. This is better then going to a breeder.
|