Re: Is this too much for a 3 year old?
Posted 12/2/2015 11:41:09 PM by mnmsoinlove
Posted by Chai77
Posted by InShock
Posted by alli3131
Posted by Chai77
Posted by alli3131
IMO no its not too young. They are just giving suggesting on working on it at home....its not like they fail if they don't know the words.
My DS is in daycare 5 days a week 10hrs a day. I pay for them to teach not just watch and play with him. My DS started a journal in his 3 yo room (he was only 2.5 at the time) and its great to see the progression they make. Now he is in the PreK room and he can write and is working on reading (very basic).
IMO its never to young to start this. As for the behavior its normal. All kids have off days. My DS's teacher told me he had bad listening weeks etc. I would just talk to him and remind him of behavior things.
I disagree. What the OP described is developmentally inappropriate for a three year old. And there is a risk of putting pressure on the child, making him/her not enjoy school, acting out behavior if you demand they do things that are beyond their capabilities. I am in the field.
Ok we disagree. There are plenty of places that seem to follow this approach. I personally am glad my DS goes to a daycare/school that is proactive with it. There is no pressure and we put zero on him.
Thing is, it's not really an opinion thing. Developmental appropriateness is based on loads of research. There's a reason certain things are taught at certain ages. Children are cognitively and physically capable of doing things at different ages. When we push them too early, that can be a problem. At 3, children should be developing their fine motor skills through play-based activities like playdoh and coloring. They are NOT ready to be writing letters.
Yes, exactly what I was going to respond.
I have a doctorate degree in child psychology, so I am giving a qualified judgement here. These kind of demands, while unfortunately common in preschools and day care centers, are developmentally inappropriate and potentially detrimental to young children. As the pp stated, this is RESEARCH based, not just an opinion.
And yes, I would pull my child out of that program if that is truly the way it is. I would not want my three year old exposed to that. They should be playing, socializing, learning to properly hold a crayon, learning their colors and shapes at this age.
Ita! I think it's very hard to find daycare/preschools that know what dap is. Like I stated earlier I had to look high and low and take my dd to school 20 mins away from where we live because I did not want my 3 year old doing dittos. I went to one school and asked about dittos and the director was so enthusiastic to show me a huge stack of handwriting and math sheets the kids do. I honestly think teachers think they are doing right by children when it really is not appropriate. Children learn through play and that is what they should be doing.
|