Re: Miley Cyrus
Posted 6/19/2015 8:59:16 AM by Chai77
Posted by Kitten1929
Posted by Chai77
This is so not about Miley Cyrus, but the whole issue of identity is coming up now. And I have been thinking about the NAACP chapter head Rachel Dolezal being exposed as biologically Caucasian, but saying that she has identified as African American since age five. Most people are saying she is crazy and a liar. But is it any different than Caitlyn Jenner identifying as female? What is the difference?
The difference is that Caitlyn Jenner cannot just take off her femininity when it suits her. Rachel Dolezal can conveniently appropriate whatever aspects of black culture she wants for her benefit and discard of what she doesn't. You can't be transracial. What she's done is essentially want to claim blackness without the inherent identity. She's defrauded hundreds of people with her claim. She's involved in lawsuits where she claims she's white! Caitlyn Jenner is not male one day abd female the next - she has undergone the necessary surgeries and therapies to transition genders. On the surface people think these are two similar situations but they're not. Caitlyn Jenner is not claiming to be something she's not - she's absolutely female. Rachel Dolezal is not absolutely black.
Can you or someone explain then how you can identify as three genders, but it is not possible to be "transracial"?? If you feel like you have three genders, doesn't that imply some switching back and forth?
Rachel is not the best example because clearly she withheld the full truth, making her a liar but it got me thinking.
And I don't think Caitlyn has had the full physically transforming surgery. So what does that mean? Genetically Caitlyn will always be male. No surgery will change that she has XY chromosomes. Race is a social construct, so being transracial seems plausible to me.
|