Re: Recommendation on breast pump
Posted 1/6/2015 3:27:18 PM by MrsT809


Posted by LML


Posted by MrsT809


Posted by LML

I have both of them and I like them both, but I like the Hygeia slightly more. The Hygeia has separate controls for suction and speed. Medela only allows you to control suction. The Hygeia is a closed system and Medela is not. That means that there's always condensation in the Medela tubes and for some reason that really bugs me. Both of them do a good job at getting the milk out and that's really the bottom line though.



You can see if the hygeia parts work with the medela. I posted today that I tried ameda parts with my pis and it worked great. The ameda pieces make the pis a closed system.



You can use the Hygeia and Medela parts interchangeably, but that doesn't make the medela pump into a closed system. The Ameda parts work in a different way so maybe that does make a closed system, but I wouldn't guarantee it.



Yeah I have no guarantees but the lc at the nicu told me the ameda piece that does the job of medela's membrane does not allow any transfer of air. I've never had any condensation in the tubes using it that way.
Print Post      Close Window