Re: Absolutely sick over this NYPD shooting/murder
Posted 12/22/2014 3:49:56 PM by justbeachy


Posted by LeeCR7


Posted by justbeachy

Change, in abstraction is great. As a concept, it's sexy. It's rose colored and exciting. It got our President elected. It's easy to yell loudly and march across a city and decry the injustices.

But then what?



It's a great question. One of the most eye-opening aspects of all of this was learning about how differently the justice system treats police officers.

As you probably know, there is no national database that compiles accusations against police or what happens after these accusations; the National Police Misconduct Reporting Project is the first attempt to do so. When a case is brought to a grand jury, it is sent to trial 99% of the time. That may seem unbelievable, and there are very slight variations among states and federal courts, but it is true.

"U.S. attorneys prosecuted 162,000 federal cases in 2010, the most recent year for which we have data. Grand juries declined to return an indictment in 11 of them."

However, with police it is very different. There is no data on how many accusations of police misconduct make it to grand juries, although estimates are very low. And the grand jury results are almost the opposite. Of 81 cases accusing police of misconduct in Texas from 2008-2010, only 1 was sent to trial.

I could go on throwing numbers at you, telling you that even when police officers are put on trial, they are convicted at a much lower rate (68% of civilians are convicted vs 33% of police officers; of that number only 12% of officers serve any time vs nearly half of civilians), but the point is that the justice system treats police officers differently.

And to a certain extent, that is fair. Police need to be able to use force, to protect themselves. They have trained for and deserve that authority. Most of them would never abuse that privilege. But that does not mean that those who do are above the law. Yet the law is not applied fairly to them.

Worse, it is a known factor in the world of law. Often prosecutors won't bother going to the grand jury, even with a decent case, because they know an indictment is unlikely. Officers themselves know that, most likely, their greatest punishment will be losing their jobs or losing a civil suit that the department must pay for. For most of the good police officers, none of this matters. But there is no group of people that is composed of the entirely good.

So what does this mean in terms of reform? I'm not sure, to be honest. Maybe we need a special prosecutor or a jury of police officer peers, who can more fairly judge a fellow officer's action. I, personally, don't have the answer. Although the police deserve some latitude, they don't deserve a free pass under the law.And since so few of them end up having to face any consequences, it is close to what they are getting. It is something we, as a society, should look at, and protesters have a right to demand change. Nobody is above the law, not even those charged with enforcing it.


All my information comes from Nate Silver's blog (the guy who has correctly predicted most of the recent elections--fairly unbiased)
http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/allegations-of-police-misconduct-rarely-result-in-charges/

and from the National Police Misconduct Reporting Project (NPMRP), which only started in 2009, so this information is new.
http://www.policemisconduct.net/

Take a look at both if you have the time. They are very interesting reads.



Thank you for your thoughtful response. While I don't think we see eye to eye on this issue, I appreciate your tone and your ability to remain unemotional in your response. If more people discussed the issues in your fashion, we could make progress!

You're right. Based on the statistics you quoted, it does appear that there is a disconnect somewhere in the system. But, I wholeheartedly believe in my fellow peers on a grand jury to make those decisions. When you speak of police officers NOT being convicted at trial, that is because a jury of peers finds that to be true. Does that mean the system is broken? To discount their efforts and say that the system is broken is dismissive of their thoughtful examination of the evidence.

I could possibly support a National Database - with the condition that any reported misconduct is documented and proven in a court of law. As I'm sure you agree, we live in an overly litigious society, and cops are an easy target for false accusations. Like you mentioned, most police officers do not abuse their power.

All of this is upsetting. It's still raw and emotional. Eventually we all need to come to the table and discuss reform, legislation, and ways to rebuild trust.
Print Post      Close Window