Re: Absolutely sick over this NYPD shooting/murder
Posted 12/22/2014 9:43:37 AM by gina409
Posted by MrsA1012
Posted by sometimesmommy
Posted by justbeachy
Curious.. As we become angrier and more divided, it got me thinking about the future....
For those who support the protests- what is your desired outcome/goal? I hear buzz words like 'reform' and 'consequences' but I'd love to understand what that looks like in reality.
We pride ourselves - as a country - on having due process. We created a system where we have a jury decide the outcome - not a single, potentially partial judge. So in these scenarios, when an indictment isn't handed down because a jury of peers didn't find enough evidence to move ahead, what are protesters suggesting should be done to avoid similar fates down the road? How would evidence be assessed? Cases be judged? Am I missing the mark here?
What more can be done to weed out bad apples of the police department? What reforms need to happen? Sensitivity training? I can't envision what protesters are looking for in terms of 'training officers.'
Change, in abstraction is great. As a concept, it's sexy. It's rose colored and exciting. It got our President elected. It's easy to yell loudly and march across a city and decry the injustices.
But then what?
I dont have the answers but clearly see the system is broken. What we need is open, transparent dialogue and a system where when incidents happen that a truly neutral agency spearheads an investigation. Also having cops of a different race patrolling in a community needs to change-there needs to be diversity because based on what I am hearing, many feel that having predominantly caucasian cops in a black neighborhood is challenging, not just for the officer but the very people that need protecting so that needs to change. I really have to sit and give it thought but as I said open dialogue with the people capable of instituting change-the first task is to identify who would make up said group.
You make some valid points and I don't have a problem with an open mindedness to reforms,if needed. However, I don't understand how putting more minority cops in minority high crime areas will change anything. If a cop is black he needs to uphold the law in the same way a white cop would. He cannot be more lenient or behave differently. A black cop would have had to call out a Michael Brown or an Eric Garner. Also, do we really think a gang banger or other criminal cares what race the cop is. Are they going to say , "gee , he's black. I feel more understood, I think I will behave differently. It is also a slippery slope. What's to then say, we feel uncomfortable having a black cop in a majority white area? Where does this go? The only benefit I can see is that if there is an incident and both the civilian and the cop are black , no one can blame race. Finally,I think a problem with all these discussions, is that most of the people on this site live in safe, suburban , majority white neighborhoods and don't have a true understanding of what cops really face in these dangerous , inner city areas.I don't pretend to have any first hand experience,but from my contact with those that do, I think the lawlessness and Wild West mentality that is pervasive in these areas would be hard for us to understand. It is an enormous challenge to an officer of any color to keep civilians/themsleves safe in this kind of environment. In neighborhoods with 200 active gangs ,you don't know who is armed and who will shoot you for no reason. That would make any human being more frightened/ on edge and must quicker to act with force. It's a very hard situation.
I read somewhere the chief officer who sent cops to bodega was African American and also the highest commanding officer on scene was as well
I agree with you 100 percent. 99 percent of us have no idea what it's like to live in these are as and be a cop in there areas
|