Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop
Posted 12/4/2014 12:08:00 PM by Kitten1929
Posted by PhyllisNJoe
Posted by MandJZ
Posted by PhyllisNJoe
Posted by MandJZ
Posted by MandJZ
Posted by PhyllisNJoe
Posted by MandJZ
Posted by PhyllisNJoe
Posted by MandJZ
. Would I, personally, choose to listen to a police officer if I was ever in a situation where one was telling me to do something? Yes, likely I would. But if I am not being questioned or charged with a crime I do not have to.
You don't have to. But you would. That's the point a lot of people are trying to make.
Nobody answeres my question before. Do you think if this man, same situation, same build, same everything, was white - that these officers would have reacted using the same force ? My answer is yes. Same protocol no matter what race the person is. I feel like a lot of people are saying it's because he was black that this cop didn't care enough to stop and check on him.
Personally? No. I don't think he would have used the same force. But that wasn't really my point.
And, even if I would choose to listen...if I didn't, do I then deserve to be attacked or have force used against me?
Yes. If you resist arrest, you will be taken down to. Non threatening position so u can be arrested.
So yes
I'm sorry you believe that the reason force was used is bc of his race. You are lucky enough to not be close with people - white people - who have been in and out of the system who have been forced to surrender for arrest before.
I have. It's not a pretty scene though absolutely necessary
I'm not talking about resisting arrest. I'm talking about what I said above. If I have not done anything, and am not being questioned or arrested, and I choose not to listen to something a police officer says, do I deserve to have force used against me?
ETA: with all due respect, you have no clue who I know and what their situations are. So you don't know if I am "close with" any one, of any race, who has been in and out of the system.
To add to this: I have the privilege of working with young men and women of color at a private special education school in Manhattan. These kids commute into the city from the boroughs, from terrible areas where the things they encounter and witness are unimaginable. All so that they could have a good education and hope to get out of the cycle they live in. And yet, these amazing, fantastic teenagers who are hard working, studious, ambitious kids, are harassed DAILY on the subway and on their walk by police officers. ONLY based on how they look. And I HAVE witnessed it firsthand, because I have sat in the subway car with them on class trips, and seen it. With my own eyes. Kids doing NOTHING other than wearing baggy clothes and having corn-rows. Being harassed by police officers.
I had a 15 year old boy come into my office at 9am one morning IN TEARS because he was searched on the subway that morning. He was standing, listening to music, and he was stopped and searched and had his iphone confiscated because the officer assumed it was stolen. That he couldn't have afforded it otherwise.
Tell me how that is fair?
If it isn't about race, explain that to me.
In this case, no. That isn't fair. That is a jerk in the mix. It happens. Everywhere. There are bad people in every walk of life. And yes, even police officers.
AGAIN, in the case of what this thread is about - I don't think that's what happened.
But that's my point. If there are bad eggs everywhere, then everyone should be held to the same standard. I think it's very relevant that cases involving police officers go to trial far less than the greater population. That, to me, reflects an injustice in the system.
Injustice in the system. It's everywhere. Not just against people of color.
Plenty of rapists, murderers, drug dealers, child molesters,... you name it, get out to commit these crimes again because of the injustice in the system. The laws are the laws with lots of loop holes which work in the favor of many people. Criminals as well as law enforcement.
The part of this that just kills me is that you and a lot of people believe this police officer killed this guy because he's black. That just boggles my mind!!! Where's the proof in that statement? Is there a record of this officer killing other black men? Only? Is there record showing he only goes after black men? Has he never arrested a white person before? That's what really gets me.
Please show me where ANYONE said he was killed specifically because he was black?
|