Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop
Posted 12/4/2014 11:59:44 AM by MandJZ


Posted by PhyllisNJoe


Posted by MandJZ


Posted by PhyllisNJoe


Posted by MandJZ


Posted by PhyllisNJoe


Posted by MandJZ

. Would I, personally, choose to listen to a police officer if I was ever in a situation where one was telling me to do something? Yes, likely I would. But if I am not being questioned or charged with a crime I do not have to.




You don't have to. But you would. That's the point a lot of people are trying to make.

Nobody answeres my question before. Do you think if this man, same situation, same build, same everything, was white - that these officers would have reacted using the same force ? My answer is yes. Same protocol no matter what race the person is.
I feel like a lot of people are saying it's because he was black that this cop didn't care enough to stop and check on him.



Personally? No. I don't think he would have used the same force. But that wasn't really my point.

And, even if I would choose to listen...if I didn't, do I then deserve to be attacked or have force used against me?



Yes.
If you resist arrest, you will be taken down to. Non threatening position so u can be arrested.

So yes

I'm sorry you believe that the reason force was used is bc of his race. You are lucky enough to not be close with people - white people - who have been in and out of the system who have been forced to surrender for arrest before.

I have. It's not a pretty scene though absolutely necessary



I'm not talking about resisting arrest. I'm talking about what I said above. If I have not done anything, and am not being questioned or arrested, and I choose not to listen to something a police officer says, do I deserve to have force used against me?

ETA: with all due respect, you have no clue who I know and what their situations are. So you don't know if I am "close with" any one, of any race, who has been in and out of the system.




I am not talking about having a student, or knowing, or learning in a lecture here. I'm talking about family, friends, neighborhoods. I do not know you well enough, but I am pretty sure you didn't grow up living in and around crime.

I did.

That is where I say "close to". And again, I say YES, an officer of the law asks you something, you respectfully answer. If he asked you what time it is and you said 12 and he throws you on the floor because you were wrong? Ok, that's unnecessary. But in this case and a lot of others like it, it wasn't as simple of a situation as that.


I am not saying that there are no racist cops. Or people for that matter. What I am saying is in this particular case, I FEEL, my opinion, my thought on the matter, is that it had nothing to do with race and everything to do with size and resisting.

I guess you also have a background in IAB? Sounds like it



Your personal experiences and relationships don't trump mine. And once again, you don't know how I grew up.

ETA: not that I ever make a point of being disrespectful to anyone, I don't think I NEED to answer someone respectfully simply because of his or her job. Sorry.
Print Post      Close Window