Re: Recommend your SUV
Posted 10/19/2014 3:41:02 PM by BlackJack96

We recently bought an Acadia Denali after I did a lot of research.

Our requirements were: AWD, seats at least 7, easy access to third row, not a minivan.

Here's what we found:

The Majority of 3 row SUVs have a 2-3-2 seating configuration. If you have a 60/40 bench in the 2nd row it's a real PITA to get into the 3rd row. Also in some cars with 2 carseats in the 2nd row it's hard to get someone to fit in the middle 2nd row. So depending on your seats and size of 2nd row you can only take 2 more passengers despite having 3 seats left. (i.e. acura mdx, mb GL, BMW X5, lexus gx) The pilot i believe is 2-3-3 but you have same issue with getting to the 3rd row.

Some 3 row SUVs have a 2-2-2 configuration with captains chairs which allow easy 3rd access. What this means is that if you put 2 car seats (boosters) in the 2nd row with captains chairs and you effectively can only take 2 more passengers. (Ford Explorer, Dodge Durango, Hyndai Santa Fe)

I think the Vovlo xc90 has a 40/20/40 2nd row. which is unique (and very Minivan like) This model is dated and due to be replaced in 2015 so if you're looking at this you may want to hold out. That to me was the big barrier to this car.

The mazda cx-9, nissan pathfinder, Inifiniti jx (now qx or whatever they renamed it) have a 2nd row seat that moves forward with a car seat for easy 3rd row access. However, you have still have the issue with fitting a 3rd passenger in between car seats in the 2nd row AND you only have 2 seats in the 3rd row.

The optimal seating arrangement with 2 kids in car seats is a 2-2-3 (with captain's chairs in the 2nd row) and a 3 seater 3rd row. (Ironically a minivan is probably the best fit here....) The ONLY SUVs with this seating configuration are:
Toyota Highlander and the GM Lambda triplets (Chevy Traverse, Buick Enclave, GMC Acadia). The highlander I think has a more ergonomic dash and console. However, trunk is unusable for anything more than a run to CVS without folding the 3rd row down basically making you choose between people or cargo. Also fitting 3 in the 3rd row is a tight squeeze.

The Lambdas are ideal. We looked at the Acadia. The Chevy is lowest priced model the Acadia is the "middle" and the Enclave is the "luxury". Personally, I like the look of the Acadia since it looks like a "truck" and not a bubble like the other two. The denali package makes it as luxurious as the Enclave. (the enclave has a little more wood on the inside but that's about it).

Hope that helps...

Print Post      Close Window