Re: Is anyone watching Oprah??
Posted 7/11/2005 8:26:28 PM by Ambersmom


Posted by Redhead


Posted by june262004


Posted by Marcie


Posted by ambersmom

I can't even fathom feeling so detached from your child(ren). These women are psychos, PP or not. I had it and NOT once did I feel like inflicting harm on my baby. That's as lame as an excuse as drinking and driving.



thank you. If anyone is feeling ill against a child - go get help - there is help everywhere.



Yes there is help. Its sad and its sick but IT could happen to you your sister or your neighbor.


OK i am now watching bits and pieces of this and i have to say i do not think these women are "psychos". Although they did actually have a psychotic break, you are using that in a very demeaning way. This can and does happen. I do not think of it as an excuse. IMO you have to be completely out of your mind, completely helpless, completely detached to kill your child.
It isn't an excuse...Sometimes i think people who aren't well prepared or well situated FREAK OUT once they have a child and then blame it on PPD. But who am i to say exactly since i am not in the home of these women.

As much as i am horrified about what that woman did who drowned her 5 children i think she was having a psychotic break. She was showing symptoms for a LONG time and tried to get help which fell on DEAF EARS. Her husband knew she was sick and having problems yet CONTINUED to isolate this woman and have more children with her. IMO HE should be on trial and is MORE LIABLE than the mother.

It is truly a sad disease



Honestly, I'm not here for a debate. I expressed my feelings and I'm not retracting them or fluffing over them. I have no problem labeling a woman who cuts off her 11 month old daughter's arm as psycho, because that's the only way (as a mother) as I can see her. Maybe it's a blanket statement, maybe it's demeaning but that's how I feel. Ill or not, murder is murder. Sorry the "awwh, she was having a mental moment/bad day" doesn't cut it for me when her child is fighting for their life, struggling as they are being drowned, or begging Mommy to stop. How can you look into that child's eyes, hear their voices AND NOT FEEL COMPASSION?? In the case of Andrea Yates, she could have walked those babies into any TX police station and LEFT them, let them know she was a danger to them. Heck, she could have left them home alone and they would have been in a far better predicament. Free will gave her the choice to drown them.

My empathy is saved for the true victims, the children. I wouldn't feel any differently if it was a sex offender, etc.

There was a nut in CA that used his 17 month old daughter as a shield while the cops open fired on him yesterday. Labeling his actions as a psychotic episode isn't going to bring back that little girl or give the mother who now can't hold her daughter in her arms comfort.
Print Post      Close Window