Re: LIRR Strike Question
Posted 7/9/2014 2:26:24 PM by Mill188


Posted by CookiePuss

17% over 7 years for a job with other benefits such as pensions and paid medical seems very fair. If 17% was the compromise, the first number may have been ridiculous.

The other issue being reported as a road block is what new employees would pay towards their health care.

What are the issues that the union is opposing other then what is being reported? Because based on the above, it seems like the union is being unreasonable and I think it's unfair to commuters and the MTA workers who I am sure want to work.



The first offer of the unions WAS ridiculous. It's hard to quantify the pensions. LIRR workers don't pay into social security - they pay into railroad retirmenet. They also do not receive SS benefits when they retire. The "pension" part is a very small part of their income after retirement most of the income comes in the form of RR retirement (which would be like your or my social security but is at a higher rate).

Right now it takes the average LIRR worker 5 years to get up to 100% of their pay grade. So they get hired as say a station cleaner and are told the salary is say $40K a year (made up number) - the first year they will only make say $32K (80% of their salary); the next year $34K, etc. until they reach 100% of their salary. The MTA wants to extend that amount of time for each individual union by 2 years. The MTA wants to abolish night differential pay. Try finding someone who wants to work the 2:30 am train from Penn without offering an incentive. I wouldn't do it. The MTA wants to abolish incentives for achieving additional certifications.

Complicating matters is that there isn't just one union. There are 7 different unions trying to come to contract terms.

Why the MTA let it get to this point is beyond me. The contract expired FOUR years ago. The unions have been asking for mediation since before the contract expired. The unions have also offered to extend the deadline. Now this I'm sure was done to push the strike closer to election time. Chat Icon

Cuomo has decided not to get involved (I guess it's only a state agency when he wants to put some cronies in charge). The MTA has been told twice what to do to avoid a strike, and they don't like the answer.

The unions were given a sensible compromise package by the presidential review boards that they were willing to take.

The people being screwed are the commuters.....eventually both the MTA and the LIRR workers will both come out ahead.

If this wasn't so devastating for LI's economy, it would actually be a fascinating case study in labor relations....
Print Post      Close Window