FINDING OUT THE SEX WITHOUT DH KNOWING!
Posted 11/5/2013 11:15:25 AM by superdupergirl

Humor me and read this whole thing.

So a friend of mine did this a few years ago when she was pregnant with twins. She really wanted to know the sex of the babies, but her DH was adamant about it being a surprise. They already had one son and she really wanted a girl, she knew if both babies were boys she was going to be disappointed and she wanted time to come to terms with that. Still, her husband felt very strongly about not finding out.

She secretly found out the sex (of course she was having two boys!) and never told anyone. She played it off like she didn't know the whole time, bought everything gender neutral and acted surprised when they were born. To this day her husband has no idea she found out the sexes. She never felt bad about it and made no apologies for it.

When she told me this (I'm a work friend so she knew it was safe to share with me—it wasn't going to cross over to her personal life) I was shocked. I couldn't believe someone would do that. I remember thinking that it was kind of horrible to be sneaky and dishonest about such a monumental moment in your life. It just seemed wrong.

Two years later I was the one having a baby. My DH and I decided not to find out (I was on the fence, he was 1000% against finding out, so I went with him on it). It was our first child and I didn't have a preference at all. Honestly, I was so excited about the idea of a little boy or a little girl. But then over the course of my pregnancy I became convinced I was having a boy. I don't know why, I just felt very strongly that it was a boy. My DH did too. We just knew it was a boy. Then I gave birth to a beautiful baby girl. I was shocked. Not just because I had a girl, but because my first feeling was disappointment. It turns out, I spent so much time thinking of the baby inside my belly as a boy, I guess I started bonding with "my son" and when that didn't turn out to be the case, it really left me feeling unsettled. My DH went out to share the "It's a Girl!" news with our families who were all waiting in suspense —there were tears, there were hugs etc.—it was a beautiful moment for all of them, but of course I wasn't a part of any of it. I was in recovery trying to wrap my brain around my new daughter. I kept asking my DH if he was happy and he kept telling me he was thrilled. You could see him beaming. But it took me a day to get over the feeling that the baby boy I thought I was carrying, didn't exist. It was a very weird, surprising feeling.

Of course now I'm so incredibly grateful I have a girl. My sweet baby girl. In fact, I'd be THRILLED if we had another girl.

So as we start talking about going for #2, my DH is again 1000% against finding out. He likes doing things the old school way and just really loves the idea of a surprise and the tradition of delivering the news. Under no circumstances does he want to know. But I do. I really do. I don't care about a gender specific room or buying pink or blue stuff, I just don't want that feeling that I had last time. Even if it only lasts a second, it was awful to feel a tinge of disappointment as you hear the news of your baby being born. I still feel sad about my reaction.

So now I'm suddenly in this place where I'm thinking about what my friend did years ago. I mean, it would give DH what he wants and it would give me what I want—everybody is happy, everybody wins, right? Yet, something in me feels incredibly guilty for even thinking about it. I don't want to spend my entire pregnancy feeling dishonest. I wish I could just tell him I'm finding out, but it would only work if he had no idea I knew. Otherwise, he'd be reading into everything and it would just get weird and he'd ending up knowing too.

I know if I insisted we find out, DH would let me have my way, but I also know he'd be really disappointed on the inside. That's why I'm wondering if finding out and not telling him is actually the better way because we both get what we want.

Anyway, I thought it would be a fun topic of discussion for us. I'd love to hear your thoughts on the matter.

(Oh, and don't mind the fake name. I'm a longtime poster, but I know lots of people on here personally and I can't allow my secret fantasy to get out there! )Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window