Re: Please read this article- All smoke detectors are NOT created equal
Posted 10/13/2013 6:18:36 PM by GoldenRod
Interesting counter-point to the ionization alarms, from an experienced Fire Chief:
http://consumerist.com/2010/08/25/fire-chief-most-smoke-alarms-are-useless-endanger-users/
Fire alarms make you feel safe, but an Albany, Calif. fire chief says it’s a false sense of security. Speaking to the San Francisco Chronicle, the chief says most people equip their homes with cheaper ionization alarms, which detect smoke via an electric current and can lead to false alarms (such as reacting to overcooked food) while missing genuine dangers until it’s too late. The chief says people should opt for slightly more expensive photoelectric alarms, which use more accurate light beams to alert fire victims.
According the story, ionization alarms run about $10 while photoelectric versions cost $15.
The chief tells the Chronicle:
Ionization alarms are the ones that go off when you burn your toast, and they can be so annoying that nearly a quarter of the people who own them turn them off. But even more important, they go off a lot slower than photoelectrics, and by the time you hear them it can be too late. We absolutely have to get rid of them.
I'm still rooting for the mix of sensors options. Hedge your bets in both directions.
|