Re: Smoke detectors in every bedroom?
Posted 10/12/2013 11:42:25 PM by GoldenRod


Posted by CSK


Posted by NervousNell

I also want to add something that recently scared the crapp out of me.
I saw this on 20/20
There are apparently 2 kinds of smoke detectors out there- and the one that is cheaper and most common does NOT detect a fire as fast as the other kind.
I don't recall the 2 types or any of the technical details but it was scary./
They showed demonstrations of fires and the standard smoke detectors were NOT going off for at least 10 minutes - while the other kind detected the fire and rang much faster.
They spoke of a case of a woman's 4 children all perishing in a fire because of this.
Chat Icon
After watching it- DH went out and replaced all our smoke detectors.
The new ones were about double the price but well wroth the money.;
I am sorry I don't recall more details- but I will try to find the 20/20 episode.
It was so eye opening!

ETA- this article pretty much sums it up concisely.
All smoke detectors are NOT created equal
This is what you need to know:

An ionization, a photoelectric and a combination smoke detector sat above the blaze. A mere 44 seconds after the flaming fire began, the ionization alarm was the first to sound. As the flames grew and licked dangerously close at the arm of a chair located in the room, the other alarms took more than double the time to sound off.

After two minutes and 38 seconds, the photoelectric alarm went off and the combination alarm sounded soon afterward — two minutes and 59 seconds after the fire began.

A two or three-minute delay can make a big difference in a fire emergency, especially since the blaze doubles in size every minute.


I have in all rooms, the garage and basement

I'm not doubting the report, but when I did research on this, the issue is they test differently, one is more sensitive to smoldering while the other to flaming fires. We intentionally have a mix. The ionic ones I have we're half the price of the photoelectric



You definitely need a mix of both types. We have some of each. If you have only ionic ones, you're going to have the exact same problem you witnessed on the 20/20 show, but with smoke inhalation. It may not get extremely hot in a room, but you could suffocate from the smoke. The photoelectric ones will detect that, but not the ionic ones.

http://blog.allstate.com/ionization-vs-photoelectric-smoke-alarm/
http://www.nfpa.org/safety%20information/for%20consumers/fire%20and%20safety%20equipment/smoke%20alarms/ionization%20vs%20photoelectric.aspx
Print Post      Close Window