Re: Would I be a really nasty neighbor?
Posted 7/24/2013 5:26:49 PM by seaside
Posted by ElizaRags35
Posted by Chatham-Chick
Posted by seaside
I told a friend about this thread today, and I mentioned that I was asked "wtf is wrong with you" for saying that excluding a whole group like that is discrimination, whether or not it's intentional.
She asked me what kind of online community tolerated that and functioned like that.
I told her I've been surprised by things I've seen on here before, but that kind of grossness wasn't nearly the most appalling, ignorant, or ugly thing I saw on this thread.
I hardly view this situation as discriminatory. The poster was not told she couldn't participate in the block party because she was Jewish.
It could be viewed as discriminatory if they hold the block party on Yom Kippur annually.
Tolerance and respect of one's religion/beliefs is one thing, but explain to me why a multi-religious community must observe a specific religion's holiday as well?
Courtesy.
Respect.
It's the neighborly thing to do.
This, plus it is discrimination--simply because it categorically excludes all members of a religion. Again--it may be unintentional discrimination, borne of ignorance--but it is discrimination. When you make a rule or a screen that operates to categorically block out a race, religion, sex, etc., you are categorically excluding people because of their status.
Do they owe you a legal duty? No--but it's discrimination, just like if a condo board in an apartment held their annual party on Easter Sunday, when Christians go to church. It may be intended or not (I have no idea)--but it operates to exclude people based upon the group they belong to. Here, it's a minority group that (clearly) many on LI are biased against to begin with.
ETA: that "clearly" was inspired by some of what I saw here today, but not by anyone quoted here.
|