Re: Would I be a really nasty neighbor?
Posted 7/24/2013 5:24:49 PM by Goobster


Posted by brownie


Posted by Chatham-Chick


Posted by seaside

I told a friend about this thread today, and I mentioned that I was asked "wtf is wrong with you" for saying that excluding a whole group like that is discrimination, whether or not it's intentional.

She asked me what kind of online community tolerated that and functioned like that.

I told her I've been surprised by things I've seen on here before, but that kind of grossness wasn't nearly the most appalling, ignorant, or ugly thing I saw on this thread.




I hardly view this situation as discriminatory. The poster was not told she couldn't participate in the block party because she was Jewish.

It could be viewed as discriminatory if they hold the block party on Yom Kippur annually.


Tolerance and respect of one's religion/beliefs is one thing, but explain to me why a multi-religious community must observe a specific religion's holiday as well?




I have to agree with this, I never imagined this question would start arguments because it didn't seem offensive/discriminatory or anything of the like to me...the only part I saw fault with was not replying to the OP's email.



I agree too. I just can't see how this is discriminatory. The date wasn't picked B/C the family could NOT participate. The date was picked b/c it worked best for most. I don't see a difference if the reason the OP can't participate is for religious observance or for another function. If you cannot participate, you cannot participate and the date is chosen based on what worked best for most. I just think it's unfair to expect the day for a block party to be picked based on one family's needs when there are many families to factor in. Religious commitments or whatever you have.
Print Post      Close Window