Re: "Cannibal Cop" - Guilty
Posted 3/12/2013 4:46:11 PM by ElizaRags35


Posted by Kathy042806


Posted by Aries14


Posted by springchick


Posted by FirstMate


Posted by MrsPJB2007


Posted by Christine2

I'm actually shocked at this verdict. I don't actually think he was ever going to act on his fantasies. Did he abuse his power when he used police databases, yes, and for that he should be punished. But I really think his cannibalism fetish was just a sick, sick fantasy that would never have panned out.



I'm surprised by it also. I absolutely believe this man is disturbed and sick. But I'm not sure if this is a conspiracy worthy conviction. He should have lost his job for sure for using the databases and he needs mental help. But to charge him with a crime because it was disturbing what his fantasy was? I'm just slightly worried about the slippery slope this could be in the future.

Yes I know that some will say that he was caught in some planning phase before he could do anything, but where would that end? If someone is on some fantasy website where they talk about killing their boss and they do research about the ways to kill them and talk about how they would like to do it because they are bored or really hate the person will that person eventually be subject to a murder conspiracy charge? How do you know the line between talking about it and plotting it?

Like I said, I am glad this man is no longer a cop and I believe his obsession is one that is unhealthy and likely requires therapy (counseling or drug) - but I guess I'm just a little fearful of how this kind of conviction could be used to file charges against anything you do/say on the internet.



I absolutely agree. I find this verdict to be scary quite frankly. There were no overt criminal acts committed. Convicting based upon thoughts alone is very, very troublesome.



agree, I am actually shock that this was the verdict too. I know its scary and the guy is crazy but I am actually worry what this verdict is going to mean in the future.



I think what people are forgetting is that for a conspiracy charge it has to be proven that the subject took steps to carry out a crime. So we are not talking about some guy that just talked about his fansty. He went beyond that and did things to show he was serious about doing his plan.

Luckily, law enforcement doesnt have to sit around and wait for him to actually hurt or kill someone to arrest and charge him. Could you imaigne the uproar if there was no "conspiracy Charge" then?




I agree. Fantasy is "make believe". He didn't make believe any of those women that were named. They were all real. If it was some sort of fantasy, then use fake people. I wouldn't want to have been one of his "fantasy victims" in real life. There was talk of money exchanged. Whether he would've gone through with it or not, thank god we'll never find out. And ftr, I'm nypd & disgusted by this



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window