Re: college savings?
Posted 2/3/2013 11:43:15 AM by Karen
Posted by MaZz
Posted by Karen
Posted by Hofstra26
Posted by Karen
Most financial advisors are not fan of 529's, quite frankly, because they can not make any money off of them. You can go on-line right now and set up a 529 plan by yourself.
Of course they would much rather see you in an investment that is commission-based.
I agree a financial advisor wants to make money buuuuuuuut there are so many other investment options out there worth looking into as well that can garner you a great return on your investments.
For us, even when I opened the 529 on my own, I didn't like that you couldn't touch the money once it was invested, it HAD to be used for education expenses, and if I withdrew for anything else it would be taxed and I would be penalized. I wasn't surprised to hear the same concerns from my financial guy. I had already considered that down side to the 529 when I opened it. Ultimately, I just much preferred having an investment where I had full access to my money when I want it and for what I want it for............just in case.
I am not criticizing anyone who uses them, I just felt it didn't fit our needs.
The whole point of a 529 is setting aside funds for college/trade school - so the argument that you can't touch it for anything else is irrelevant to me. I don't want to touch it, that is the whole point!! The odds of neither of my children attending college/trade school is slim, so I am quite happy letting that money grow untouched.
ETA: No other investment we hold (401k, IRA) is coming near the rate of return the 529 plans are.
Sure you don't want to touch it BUT what happens if you need money bc you lost your job or had some catastrophic event? It's nice to know it is there to take in dire emergency
The money is always "there" if needed. Tap into your IRA or 401(k) for an emergency and there are tax/penalty consequences for that also. The 529 plan is not alone in that concept.
We have many other investments, so having to tap into a 529 account is really a remote possibility for us.
|