Re: Who won tonight's debate?
Posted 10/4/2012 12:10:25 PM by ElizaRags35


Posted by HeathKernandez

Mr. Etch-A-Sketch "won..."

sadly, if focused on the 'undecided' he seemed well informed but to me he just danced around issues, put some quotes in and never gave a concrete answer to the questions asked of specifics.

I also found that Romney nearly reversed every position he's been campaigning on for months. For an informed voter, this is huge. but too many people are uninformed. I also think when someone is NOT president, promising all the new & shiny things you're going to do in office is an advantage to a President who seemed to struggle in the office.

I'm struggling to understand what the role of the federal government will be under Romney. He wants to pass any and all responsibility to the States? Healthcare, education, repeals, you name it, its all on States that are already BROKE! State budgets will SKYROCKET!


I do not think Obama did well at all. He should have been more aggressive.

"A fish would not get caught if it kept its mouth shut". Perhaps the plan is to let Romney talk himself into trouble with all of the commitments and test how it plays with the right. We'll see if those positions holds muster with fact checkers. Time will tell.

I think they both did terrible but Romeny's "performance" was better.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I have to say that I was completely turned off by Romney's aggression. I thought it made him look douchey and arrogant. There were moments where I was actually yelling at my tv when he spoke.

------------------------------------
From Factcheck.org:

The Impossible Plan

However, Romney continued to struggle to explain how he could possibly offset such a large loss of revenue without shifting the burden away from upper-income taxpayers, who benefit disproportionately from across-the-board rate cuts and especially from elimination of the estate tax (which falls only on estates exceeding $5.1 million left by any who die this year). The Tax Policy Center concluded earlier this year that it wasn’t mathematically possible for a plan such as Romney’s to cut rates as he promised without either favoring the wealthy or increasing the federal deficit.

Except for saying that his plan would bring in the same amount of money “when you account for growth,” Romney offered no new explanation for how he might accomplish all he’s promised. He just repeated those promises in some of the strongest terms yet.

Romney: My number one principal is, there will be no tax cut that adds to the deficit. … I will not reduce the taxes paid by high-income Americans. … I will lower taxes on middle-income families.

But he didn’t say how he’d pull off all those things at once.
-----------------------------

Line of the night, IMO:

"And at some point, I think the American people have to ask themselves, is the reason that Governor Romney is keeping all these plans to replace secret because they're too good? Is it -- is it because that somehow middle-class families are going to benefit too much from them?"
Print Post      Close Window