Re: Thoughts on Voter ID Laws?
Posted 9/29/2012 11:10:41 AM by sameinitials


Posted by BargainMama


Posted by sameinitials

It's completely unconstitutional. It essentially amounts to a poll tax - you are forcing people to pay the government (because the IDs cost money) in order to have the ability to vote.

In fact, another state tried this not so long ago (I want to say it was TX but I'm not sure...) and it was determined to be unconstitutional



Then they should have to provide alternate forms of ID then. Birth certificate, social security card, something else with a picture, etc. It's so easy for someone to go in there and say they are who they aren't.



That's different though - my understanding is that some of the laws require a gov't issued ID, so even someone with a school-issued ID but no photo ID wouldn't be able to vote. If the law was just that people had to have some piece of identifying documentation - birth cert, SS card, credit card, library card, whatever - then it wouldn't be something that they would have to pay the state to get.

My issue with the law is the state requiring that they be paid in order for someone to vote. That is what makes it unconstitutional

ETA: I'm not opposed to the idea of having someone show an ID before voting. My issue is with how it is being accomplished. Someone shouldn't have to pay money in order to have the right to vote. It doesn't matter if its $13, $30, or $3. If a state wants to require people to have an ID in order to vote, then they should provide a non-driver's state ID for free. If a state did that, I would be fine with it.
Print Post      Close Window