September b-day, holding back for K?
Posted 9/26/2012 2:50:15 PM by mcl916

I know this topic has been discussed, but I never even considered it until today when we had DS's party with his pre-k class. One of the girls missed the cut-off (her bday is Dec 2) so she is almost a full year ahead and the mom is a teacher and said she is glad because she will have an edge, not as much pressure to catch up, etc. There were a few other teachers there as well saying they have never met anyone who held a child back regret it and it's much easier to do before they start kindergarten rather then repeating Kindergarten.

Anyway, DS's bday is Sept 25 so to me he is well in the cut-off. But socially I think maybe he is a little behind. He has trouble with big groups -although does fine in school, he is in his second year doing 5 half days a week. I never even considered leaving him back but when everyone was talking about it today it made me really think twice about it and wonder if I'd be giving him an advantage by giving him that extra year "head start". My mom did not keep my brother back (late Nov bday) and says she always regretted it because he struggled in school. My DH had a hard time in school and ended up being left back one year but he is a May bday so it had nothing to do with the cut off lol. MIL says DS is a lot like DH was so that has me concerned too. Obviously I still have a full year to think about it and make a decision but I was just curious to hear what everyone thinks, especially the teachers who see kids who were left back and if they had an advantage, and moms who have left their kids back.
Print Post      Close Window