Re: midwife vs.ob
Posted 8/21/2012 11:01:44 PM by laurenandmike619


Posted by TheDivineMrsM


Posted by laurenandmike619

I personally prefer OBs bc of their having gone to medical school. This is nothing against midwives but OBs undoubtedly have a greater amount of education and also need to be of a certain intelligence to even be admitted into med school and to pass the boards, etc. I also like that if I need an emergency c-section I will already have a relationship with my OB and will have established a certain level of trust. Plus I know that if I want to induce for a certain reason after I pass my due date, my OB has already told me that would be fine - I think a midwife would be less likely to support this decision. Again that is neither good nor bad, it's just a personal preference sort of thing.

But it is true that in many countries, midwives deliver babies - I know that this is definitely the case in the UK. Unless it's a high risk pregnancy, almost all pregnancies and births are handled by midwives.



Why would you want to induce w/o a medical reason? A midwife would probably not support that b/c it poses all kinds of potential problems for you and the baby. Some inductions go quickly and smoothly; others not so much. Your risk of a c-section dramatically increases.

Americans have some of the poorest outcomes for new mothers and newborns in the industrialized world, partly because of who we choose as our caretakers.

http://www.socresonline.org.uk/14/1/5.html

ITA that the OP needs to do her research. We all need to be informed consumers. Of course it's possible to have a great birth with an OB; there are some great doctors out there. Yes, you need to be your own advocate. Also know that hospital policies are as important as your provider.



I specifically said if I decided I wanted to induce "for a certain reason." I didn't say for no reason whatsoever. I'm not here to debate and I was very fair in my statement of why I personally chose to use a medical doctor instead of a midwife.

Side note: According to americanpregnancy.org, risk of stillbirth increases after 37 weeks. I know that at 40 weeks, if my baby isn't here yet, I'll want to be VERY closely monitored and if there's any kind of issue (placenta deteriorating, amniotic fluid becoming too low, etc.) I will want my baby in my arms instead of my belly. My SIL had issues with her placenta after 37 weeks and decided to induce at 40 weeks exactly even though she didn't technically need to at the moment. Both of her babies were beautiful and 100% baked so I don't like to judge any mother who is making a decision to induce - sometimes you just need to go with your gut.
Print Post      Close Window