Re: Baker refuses to take EBT cards...
Posted 8/16/2012 10:36:46 AM by JennyPenny
Posted by KLSbear
Posted by Robin
Before I say anything, I want to preface it by saying that my mom was on WIC when we were kids. It was for a very short time, but I distinctly remember eating welfare peanut-butter on white bread and box macaroni and cheese with hot dogs in it for like a year straight. But its not intended to be a system that provides whatever you want, best of the best. It is a system that provides enough to live on, until you can get back on your feet. But I think its silly to make welfare so comfortable and plush that it encourages people to stay on it for longer than they need to. It makes me batty when I see people shopping at Whole Foods with a welfare card. Welfare is intended to get you through a hard time, not to provide the luxury items, and yes, organic, specialty pies are a luxury.
I do understand what people are saying about the fruit/vegetable component and I teach in a Title 1 school (100% free lunch) and see what atrocious things that these kids bring for snack (bodega gummy worms and Hi-C?..or my personal fave: bag of marshmallows) I am completely for education and access to healthy food. I work in a food desert and its impossible to buy something healthy, but I can buy candy and liqueur 10 places. I am more commenting on the specific pie dilemma. I think that WIC or welfare should be limited to staples, that's all.
Well said! I too am all for helping someone get through a tough time, but going without a fresh pie is not desperation. I ate pancakes three nights a week and lived on a $20 a week grocery budget when I was in grad school. I didn't apply for food stamps expecting taxpayers to buy me pies. As someone else pointed out, if they really were trying to celebrate a child's birthday there are other options that are less expensive so the "pie for a party" argument is pretty weak. And for those saying the government shouldn't dictate what someone eats, I agree with that, but if they are handing out money to help with essential food purchases then it should be just for that - essential, not desserts and specialty items that are not critical to a healthy diet.
I agree with this, wholeheartedly. I have a full time job, as does DH. We are BARELY making our mortgage payments right now. BARELY. If I, a hard working person, cannot buy a $25 organic, fresh, specialty pie, then WHY should my tax dollars be buying one for someone else?? If it's 'for a party', which I think is complete BS, then they should buy one at the supermarket for half the price, or offer to bring a cake instead, which can be made for less than $5.
|