Re: Have we discussed Chik-fil-a?
Posted 8/2/2012 6:01:43 PM by JenniferEver
Posted by JAAMS
Posted by MandJZ
Posted by JAAMS
Posted by Disneygirl
This is just a case of history repeating itself. The next generation I'm sure will find another minority to pick on.
How is this cartoon any better than what it claims to fight against? This cartoon stereotypes Christians, yet it says other stereotypes are bad. It's really terrible that no one can get a point across without stereotyping other people.
I'm Christian and I'm strongly for gay rights and marriage, and I know MANY other people who are exactly the same as I am. I feel like these types of cartoons perpetuate hate. I feel really, really strongly about not fighting hate with hate, so I had to say something.
While I see your point, I think the cartoon is valid in that many of the most vocal opponents of gay rights, and those donating large sums of money to the cause, are LOUDLY citing religion and "Christian" values as their basis and their support. I totally agree with you that not ALL are this way, but I think it is important to shed light on and bring attention to those that claim that hatred and bigotry are values of their religion, a religion that as I understand really does preach about love, acceptance and tolerance. To me, these people are distorting Christianity and Christian values and beliefs, and it is important to bring that to the forefront and not sweep it under the rug.
I do see what you're saying. I think that, of course, in this particular situation we're dealing with someone who is citing religious beliefs for his political stance. My main problem with the cartoon though is that, in my eyes, it doesn't build a bridge...it's just breaking one, to be cliche. I think misunderstanding, stereotyping, and ignorance are at the heart of many problems, and this cartoon lumps all Christians into one category...thereby causing another problem. If the faces had "Ignorant" or something written across then, I'd find that more effective.
Anyway...that's just my opinion as to why this cartoon is problematic as a solution. We can agree to disagree
I don't take it as generalizing against Christians, but showing that the people who choose to hate are really not being "Christian", no matter how many bibles they carry and thump
|