Re: Banning Bake Sales?
Posted 5/10/2012 12:52:04 PM by ArmyOfBabies
Posted by Kidsaplenty
Posted by ArmyOfBabies I don't think you are giving a 5-year-old enough credit. And not to say "well stinks for the kids with allergies" but if that is your reason and defense for banning bakesales it's pretty weak. If a 5-year-old has an allergy that could be fatal then they NEED to know what can happen. If I told my DD "you can not eat such and such food b/c you have a severe allergy and you could die if you eat it" I can tell you she won't eat it. Maybe your arguement works for a 2-year-old. And again not to sound insensitive to kids with severe food allergies, but they are going to be disappointed for the rest of their life whenver there are foods of unknown origins involved. They may as well learn young how to say no.
Let's ban all flowers outdoors b/c some people have a severe allergy to pollen. No more gardens for anyone.
Maybe we should start another prohibition since some recovering alcoholics get piysically ill from the smell of it.
Why don't we get rid of organized sports, even professional ones, some people are unable to participate due to a handicap, injury, clumsiness or they just aren't athletic.
Where does it end? I'm probably going to get flamed by the parents of kids with allergies (and I don't mean to sound like an a-hole) but this is why we have a generation of entitled kids on our hands. Everyone doesn't need to be involved all the time. If no one ever learns to deal with disappointment they will lead a life of disapppointment.
You do sound like an insensitive a-hole. What you are essentially doing is saying tough sh.t to kids with allergies(and their parents) and then minimizing the fact that severe food allergies are life threatening by comparing them to sportibg injuries and seasonal allergies. Really? Is buying a banana nut bread someone brought to a bake sale really that important in your life?
And I would say that nearly every parent of a child with food allergies has explained in depth what would happen to them if theh ate the wrong thing. My son was terrified, and he is so scared to eat because "what if" goes through his mind. I have to worry every day that maybe someone brouht in a peanut laden snack by accident, or that a kid didnt wash heir hands after eqting their PB+J and my kid will die from his allergic reaction. But by all means, compare it to the runny nose and itchy eyes you get from seasonal allergies.k
Just so we're clear that I'm not being a jerk about something I know nothing about, I have a severe anaphylactic allergy that could be fatal. I don't (and never did) have/had people go out of their way to make me feel not left out. I never cared and I turned out fine. I looked out for myself.
I wasn't minimizing a fatal allergy by comparing it to sports injuries I was making a point by saying "where do we draw the line" when it comes to making sure kids don't feel left out. If no nuts are allowed then there should be no dairy, wheat, gluten, eggs, shellfish, honey, etc. allowed. There are kids with allergies to those things too. I have a friend who is allergic to citrus and breaks out in severe hives. Should that have been banned in our school? Because it wasn't.
In any case, the point of my post (which is why I kept saying "not to sound like a jerk"), is that I'm not saying "screw the kids that could die from their allergy" I'm saying if they are banning things just in case someone might feel left out, then that is wrong.
ETA: The point of me bringing the allergies into the conversation, that you failed to include, which is what my post was in response to, was that the other LIFer said "try to tell a 5-year-old they can't have something because of an allergy". My point was you HAVE to explain it and a 5-year-old would understand.
|