Re: American idol 2/28
Posted 2/29/2012 8:38:16 AM by BaysideForever

I was so disappointed.

Like take Reed for instance. I loved his performances during the auditions. And he makes me laugh. But his performance was SO boring and it was an odd/terrible arrangement. It didn't make me passionate about him at all. And the judges were still all very positive (I think they really like leaving the decisions up to America without a lot of influence). I also miss Simon. Sometimes he went too far, but he was usually on point and I liked having that real critical feedback.

I also really hate Adam. I hate how he always refers to himself as "white chocolate" and keeps saying things like he is a black woman trapped in a mans body. He emphasizes how he cooks and stays home with the kid and is an artist. Some of his mannerisms irk me. I'm all for breaking gender stereotypes and am totally accepting of the gay lifestyle/gay marriage- but the things Adam says is so weird and he claims to be happily married but after everything he says and displays- I feel like he just needs to come out and say he is gay!

And Deandre was disappointing. I remember liking him from the auditions last year and was excited they finally chose him this year. It seemed too high of an arrangement even for his high voice, off-key and in the beginning it was so amateur hour, like he didn't know how to sing into the mic correctly- so it was very inconsistent. And they praised him so highly too. BORING and many flaws!!

I could go on and on but they'd all start to sound the same.

Many of the guys performances were bad but I hope these 5 stay because I believe they could do way better down the road:

-HeeJun
-Phillip
-Reed
-Colton
-Creighton
Print Post      Close Window