Work Situation Question
Posted 1/6/2012 9:43:22 AM by jilliibabii

I'm just curious what your opinions in this situation are.

I'm a receptionist. My manager is the manager of the Operations Dept. which includes maintenance, conference services, the mailroom, and reception since we all work closely with each other. There is also a supervisor for the Operations Dept. but we generally don't report to him, only our manager. There are 5 receptionists- one has been her 20+ years, another 10+ years, I've been here 7 years, and the other 2 have been here 3 years. The receptionist that has been here 20+ years (We'll call her R) isn't very tech savvy. She shies away from all new technology and really digs her heels in everytime we have to learn a new system or program or whatever. For the past 20+ years, my company has been accommodating her. She's often been able to get out of the training and does the basics- like occupies a desk, directs guests, and answers the phone- but she does that VERY well. I blame them for letting it get to this point. We were given a small project recently (nothing serious, printing labels and assembling invites to the holiday party) and she effed it up. She missed a whole bunch of people, they were upset, and the powers that be are looking to fire her. I don't know why they don't just DO it, because they've been picking on her for months- for anything and everything- she doesn't answer the phones fast enough, she clocks in too late, then she clocks in too early, I see it and I think it's wrong what they are doing to her. She's a very soft spoken, gentle person, and I can tell she takes these things very personally.

So, in response to the project that she messed up, my manager began speaking to the receptionist who has been here 10+ years (We'll call her T) about R's work and how she needs training and how we're going to have to cover her desk next week while she gets more training. Our manager asked T to tell R about the training and how she needs to step up her game. R came to me last night very upset because she felt that our manager should've came to her directly instead of discussing her work performance with her peer/co-worker. T is NOT a manager, supervisor, senior receptionist, or anything of the like. She is equal to all the other receptionists in every way. My question is do you think it was okay for our manager to speak to T about R's work performance and then to take it a step further and ask T to address the issue with R? Is this inappropriate or unprofessional? Could our manager potentially get in trouble if R were to go to HR about this? I just feel bad for the woman and I don't know what to tell her. Of course, I won't say anything as it's not my place, but I tried to urge her to speak to our manager or to HR about it, but she refused. What do you think she should do? As a side note, our manager isn't exactly approachable. I mean she's nice enough, when she wants to be/has to be, but ya never really know how she's going to be when you approach her.

If you've made it through this novel, I applaud you! LOL! I just feel so bad for my co-worker, she's been dealing with this for a long time. The powers that be just seem to have it out for her!
Print Post      Close Window