Re: non-compete agreement
Posted 10/20/2011 5:05:16 PM by The Law Office of Kerie P. Stone

I agree with cityiwife that it is not cut and dried as to whether they are binding in NY. Law is all gray areas! Yes, it can be tough to enforce them.

My husband had one and we later had to consult an attorney friend of mine when he needed/wanted to get out of it. It was a huge mess because the company hiring him did business with his old company and THEIR contract also had the equivalent of a no-compete agreement.

I BEGGED my husband not to sign it in the first place. As an attorney, my attitude is that if you can prevent a legal headache you do it. Even if you feel that it will never be enforceable, why put yourself in a situation to possibily have to go to court to find out specifically whether your agreement will be upheld? Attorneys who litigate these issues do not come cheap and I do not think it would ever be done on a contingency fee.

The only reason my husband signed the agreement was because he felt that the company would find a way to drop him if he did not. He did not have another job lined up and he never would have expected the job that he got later.

We were very lucky that he did get out of it when he found the job he is in how. But that required a lawyer for him, a lawyer for the new company and in the end, the new company bought him out from the old company by giving the old company money to settle (they "bought" my husband!!!!). From my point of view all I see is that money changed hands but we did not see a dime of it. I still feel that his new salary might have been higher if that was not necessary. He got a nice raise for making the move but I still wonder.

The agreement stated that the laws of the state where the company was incorporated governed. If we went further we may have needed an attorney who was admitted to practice there, and it is a state where such agreements are easier to enforce. They know that when they draft these agreements. We may have been able to fight to keep it in NY but that was all questionable. I was very lucky to have a friend who was ready to help when my husband wanted to get out of the non-compete. Everyone needed to know very quickly whether the companies could settle this.
Print Post      Close Window