Re: Roof issue coming up during engineers inspection
Posted 10/16/2011 9:15:28 PM by Goobster

I was in the same position when I bought my house last year. The inspector found the roof was at the end of it's usable life. Did not find leaks in the roof that he could see, but the homeowner said there were no leaks. We did try asking for a credit. We were told no, that she felt the roof was fine and since there were no leaks, there was no issue. We agreed that we were getting a good deal, and since her obligation was only to provide a house free of leaks, that she was doing indeed.

We knew we were getting a great deal on our home and did not want to be sticklers about it. Realtor also told us the house was priced based on what was obvious, and that was that the roof was old (although not falling down, just an average older roof).

I would say if you fix the leaks, that's your only real obligation. However, you must be prepared they can walk away. How sure are you you can find another buyer for what they offered? If you are not so sure, then I wouldnt hardball.

Why not meet them halfway, if you feel you dont want to lose them? If you are ok with them walking away if they want to be sticklers about it (even if they are getting a great deal, people can be foolish and greedy), then dont budge and just fix the leaks. But be prepared to provide them with written proof of who fixed the leaks (dont have a handyman or neighbor or DH do it, get it done professionally and get it in writing such as a bill, etc).

JME anyway, only you can decide
Print Post      Close Window