Re: Death Penalty- Troy Davis
Posted 9/23/2011 11:04:05 AM by Ophelia


Posted by Deedlebugs

I believe there was enough evidence. The media likes to keep relaying that 7 of the 9 witnesses recanted but in fact there were 32 witnesses and 7 recanted. He shot a man earlier in the night with the same gun used to kill the police officer. He was pistol whipping a homeless man when the off duty PO. came to help. He shot him in the face and all witnesses agreed that the PO. was on the ground when he was shot in the chest, a second time. It has been 20 years, people grow up, think about things, and don't want blood on their hands. No one wants to be the person gave the testimony that put a man to death. I certainly believe the testimony that was taken right after the crime will always be more accurate and true then what is said 20 days, 20 months, 20 years later. He was a bad man, again he shot another man earlier in the night for yelling stuff out a car window. HE WAS NOT AN INNOCENT MAN.

ETA: some of these witnesses that recanted are criminals and inmates themselves with very jaded backgrounds. I am not sure I would believe what THEY have to say. Sitting in prison for 10+ years can definitely make you very anti-police/law


Deedle, all of these things DID happen, but they were actually attributed by the witnesses to have actually been caused by the other man that was present, Coles.

I am not arguing whether he was a good or a bad man. what I am saying is that there was enough reasonable doubt to in the very least have a new trial.

the standard for putting someone to death is and should be extremely high. that standard, with any of these doubts lingering, has not been met.

ETA: there was forensic proof that the same gun was used, NOT that Davis was the shooter. that is an important detail.

ETA: and the other man killed for murdering and dragging a man down the street, he admitted to his crime and said he'd like to do it again. different set of evidence all together.

as for the stats, these statistics cannot be looked at in a vaccumm.

X, in your beloved state of Texas, there are more black men than white me on Death Row, approximately 125 black men and 92 white men. there are also 91 hispanics.

what is the ratio of black:white:hispanics in total population density in your state?

once you start making comparisons, a different picture appears.
Print Post      Close Window