Re: I'm so torn
Posted 8/3/2011 10:10:52 AM by mamabear

I honestly don't believe you can spoil a newborn. I do believe you can set some habits (good or bad), but I mroe storngly believe that different babies have different needs, and those needs change as the baby grows.

My first daughter was an easy newborn. I held her, but not a crazy amount. She preferred to sleep in her swing or bassinet. She slept well at night, in her bassinet, for 3 months. At 3 months, she started waking more, and by 4 months, she was a horrible sleeper. She napped only in her swing, though for very long stretches. She is now 2.5 and still hates going to sleep. Once she is asleep, she is ok, but getting to sleep can be a nightmare. Breaking the swing habit for naps was a nightmare. And whenever she would wake up from sleep, she would wake up screaming bloody murder. She hated to be in her crib during the day or night. She is better now, but still usually calls for me when she wakes up.

My second daughter was a very needy newborn. I could not put her down anywhere. I couldn't go to the bathroon without her. I rarely showered--could only shower when someone else was able to hold her. We co-slept for four months. She screamed the entire time for car rides. She hated anything but my arms. She is now 1.5. She asks to go to bed at night. She goes to sleep easily in her crib (now toddler bed) and doesn't wake unless something is wrong. She naps beautifully, in her bed. When she wakes up, she hangs out by herself for awhile. She can play on her own and be very happy for extended periods. IMO, I think she actually did have a lot of needs as a young baby. Whether she had reflux (we thought she might, but could never really tell if the medicine was effective), was insecure, scared...whatever it was, I feel like her needs were met, and it let her feel comfortable and safe, and that feeling has stuck with her.

In retrospect, I wish I hadn't allowed DD1 to be so dependent on the swing. I also did CIO with DD1 at around 6 mths based on advice from my ped. I wish I hadn't. It felt wrong, and for her, accomplished nothing. it didn't turn her into a good sleeper, it made her hate going to bed even more.

I don't have any regrets about how much I held DD2. Yes, I barely slept and was tired and worn out for awhile. But I am left with precious memories of that time. As I was tucking her in just last night, I was telling her about how much I held her as a baby, and how we slept beside each other for four months and how special that was to me.

Everyone is different. Every mom. Every baby. Do what you need to do for yourself while balancing what you feel your baby needs.
Print Post      Close Window