Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?
Posted 6/13/2006 11:14:42 AM by Shanti


Posted by SweetestOfPeas


Posted by MrsS2005


Posted by SweetestOfPeas


Posted by DMcK


Posted by SweetestOfPeas


Posted by baghag


Posted by dpli

So, just to play devil's advocate......would it matter if the signs were seperated - one on either side of the window, or would people still say that he had to take down the English speaking one?



Yes. Even if the signs are separated, I think the "Speak English" one needs to be taken down.

why? I am really curious.

it is his right to say that. offensive or not, it's his right.



Is it? I am not versed in business law so I don't know. What if it said "Black" or "Hispanic" or "Asian" -- I don't think discrimination is legal. If it is, then he is well within his rights. I would just never go there.


all the sign says it to speak English. what is so wrong with that? Chat Icon I can see why it offends some people, but it's not illegal


It's discriminatory. It has the effect of turning away people who don't speak English. I think the sign by itself is offensive. When it's combined with the right to refuse service sign, IMO it's clear that the establishment is trying to discriminate against people who don't speak English. Places of public accommodation do not have the right to discriminate.

it's only discrimination if he actually refuses to serve them for that reason.

here's another point... what if it is a Chinese man orders in Chinese and no one can understand what he is ordering? since everyone is dissecting this... how can someone be served if there is no way to communicate? Chat Icon



I have been a tourist in countries where I don't speak the language and find ways to communicate - circling an order, pointing to something, etc.
Print Post      Close Window