Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?
Posted 6/13/2006 9:39:02 AM by MrsS2005
Posted by nov04libride
Posted by jmf423
Posted by nrthshgrl
Posted by baghag
Posted by SweetestOfPeas I don't see how. we either have freedom of speech, or we don't.
I don't see how this is a violation of his right free speech?
If he posted a sign saying "I only like English Speaking customers" than maybe it would qualify as free speech (albeit bigotry).
He's posted a sign saying he will only serve English-speaking customers - if he actually refuses to serve someone who doesn't speak English, then it's breaking the law. It's on par with "Colored Only" signs.
The sign doesn't actually say that he will only serve English-speaking customers. They technically are 2 seperate signs. One says to speak english and a seperate sign says that mgmt reserves the right to refuse service. By no means do I think what he is doing is right--but technically there are 2 seperate signs and we don't know how he actually acts to people who don't speak english.
I saw him on Good Morning America and he did point out that there are two separate signs and that one does not follow the other, but that the second refers to rowdy people that they reserve the right to kick out. He said people were ordering in spanish and that the employees could not understand them. His own parents were immigrants from Italy.
From the picture in the article, the English speaking sign is directly above the right to refuse service sign. Even if the signs really refer to two different things, I think it can be interpreted to mean that management will refuse service to those who do not order in English. If he really had a problem about rowdy customers, shouldn't he put up a sign about that? He seems pretty vocal about things he doesn't like. I think this is a valid discrimination complaint.
|