Re: Laffer and Brady
Posted 6/28/2011 11:06:11 AM by DancinBarefoot


Posted by neener1211


Posted by blu6385


Posted by neener1211


Posted by blu6385

I am also thinking if she was high on drugs does her confession still count?



If she was read her Miranda Rights, I'm thinking her confession will count for something.


"....she has the right to remain silent, and that anything the person says will be used against that person in court;"




i am just thinking a lawyer could argue since she was high on drugs she wasnt of "sound mind" to understand her rights.



I don't think it matters once you're read those rights. Plus, you shouldn't be under the influence in the first place. Chat Icon I've done a couple google searches to see, but don't come up with anything.





Competence to understand Miranda warnings does matter. Think of it this way - if someone has an IQ of 55 and they are read their rights, do they truly understand them??? People under the influence may or may not be competent to understand. It's a case by case decision. In this case however, I think she was "confessing" (or at least accusing) before the cops ever got the handcuffs on her.
Print Post      Close Window