Re: The type of teacher I am ... am I alone?
Posted 6/28/2011 1:15:08 AM by DWKS810

I appreciate that you are doing a great thing for your students, but I don't necessarily agree that it's always a good idea.

My husband is a teacher, can you imagine how it would look to others if he was taking female students out to restaurants? I get that it seems less odd in your case because you both go, but an allegation could be made even if you go to the bathroom and a student feels uncomfortable about something your husband says or does. They are kids and can perceive things the wrong way - how will a student who has never been on a restaurant know what it feels like to be on a date and to not be? Yeah, you can argue the finer points of this in your favor but my point is I believe it is inappropriate to be taking kids out to restaurants and socializing in ways that can be perceived as crossing a line.

My DH teaches in a rough school where several of his students are in gangs. I would love for him to reach out to them, and encourage him to talk to these students about making good choices (and he does as much as he can), but not to act further if it gets him hurt or killed. I certainly wouldn't be having them in my home no matter how big my heart is.

I just feel there are many ways that the goal you are putting out there can be accomplished without these - IMO, questionable - practices. If your students haven't been to a restaurant, bring in a menu for a restaurant and host a catered lunch with fancy tablecloths and classical music. For the holidays, donate a bag of toys to the child's family at the shelter or volunteer and spend a holiday with them there. Have inspirational, motivational lessons about where they can go in life, and encourage them to come talk to you privately for support if they need it. I think you can be "that type of teacher" in ways that won't potentially open yourself up to a world of problems despite the best of intentions and not blur boundaries for students that might need them.
Print Post      Close Window