Re: Nick Minucci- found guilty....
Posted 6/10/2006 9:17:28 AM by Shanti


Posted by DMcK


Posted by bklyngirl


Posted by 04bride


Posted by marymoon


Posted by Redhead


Posted by marymoon

Fight, yes. brutally beat another white kid with a baseball bat with little or no provocation, I don't think so.

I just don't think a white kid would have suffered the same fate.

ETA: When i say not in HB, it's because it's not an area known for gang fights and street crime

huh?



I'm saying sure kids fight, but this wasn't a bunch of kids getting into a fistfight, this was guys driving around, specificlaly looing for someone and hitting him over the head with a baseball bat.

It's not an area where you expect violence all the time. I'd feel reasonably safe walking around Howard Beach at night by myself and I wouldn't worry about being mugged, etc.

I'm just saying ot doesn't seem to me to be just a normal fight between kids, if fighting between kids cna be considered normal, it seems to go beyond that, to the point of brutalization, and I do believe it was racially motivated.



He was not driving around looking for someone to hit , the other guy was stealing cars!!!!!!!! He came to howard beach, doenst matter if hes black or white, looking to steal cars... and Minucci lost control yes, but my point it why is it a hate crime becasue he's black? How do you know he wouldnt have done that to another white kid who was , may i remind all of you again, HE WAS THERE TO STEAL CARS!!!!!!!!!



i agree. i hink if the roles where reversed, they wouldn't make a big deal out of it



I do think it is very different for a white person to call a black person the n-word. In that context, it is racist. If you think of the historical implications, it is just different. And that is how it is.

As for hate crimes, I see some of your points but I still don't see why it is worse to kill for race, religion, etc than just plain hate. I can see self defense so take that out of it but is Matthew Shepard's horrible death any different than the murder of Tafare Berryman? Tafare was the (black) Post student shot in the head by another black kid as he left a club - no reason at all but hate. Don't see the difference.

ETA: Don't get me wrong, I think so called hate crimes are disgusting, I am not justifying them, I just think hate is hate.




Print Post      Close Window