Re: Opionions on MIL situation
Posted 6/16/2011 9:40:47 AM by NextStopBabytown


Posted by Tilde


Posted by MrsSunflwr29


Posted by Tilde


Posted by Hofstra26

I may be in the minority here BUT here goes............I trust my family completely with my DD but I am still NOT a fan of ANYONE driving her around. For example, my dad is a terrible driver (I don't even feel safe in the car with him) so I wouldn't be comfortable having him drive DD around. I don't want to have to worry where she is, what store she's at, did something happen, etc. etc. I just don't really see the need for anyone to be driving my DD around at this age. (She's almost 3) I don't know, maybe I am a little crazy but I just feel better if it's just me or my DH that drives her around town.



But is your dad stuck at home with your children multiple times a week? How would he get anything done? Go food shopping? Pick up something from the dry cleaners?

No one is driving DD around for the heck of it, but they have to live their lives - they are not day care workers LOL



I look at it like a "job". they took on the responsiblity and knew what it was about. When I am work if I have to get things done I do it on my own time kwim.




Are you paying her?

I dont know - my parents have DD today. They have to go to the supermarket, a jewelry store and the mall. They have no restrictions on where they take her. They are watching my DD for free, I am not going to make their life harder by making them run their errands after I get home from work. JMO - if that is not the understanding that you have with her then I guess you have to make it clear to her and then it will be her choice if she wants to continue.




I think that there are three issues:

First, the MIL shouldn't take your kids anywhere without discussing it with the parents first. Tilde, you knew ahead of time that your parents needed to go to x, y, and z but Melissa didn't even get a heads up on the matter. That scares me to no end.
If our DD is somewhere then I want to know where she is and who she is with, no discussion. What if something happened? How would the authorities even know how to get in touch with Melissa and her DH? I would definitely bring this up to MIL directly (after discussing with DH) of course and discuss it rationally but matter of factly. I personally would rather discuss this with MIL myself instead of forcing DH to be the messenger.

Secondly, I think that you and DH both need to discuss the terms of MIL's "employment" whether voluntary or paid. It is the parents' children and the parents set the rules. If MIL agrees to the rules then that is what she needs to do. If MIL disagrees or wants to negotiate then that is her right, but ultimately the parents make the call. IMO if the parents tell MIL that they want her to stay in the house all day long (for example) and not go outside then that is their right as parents - no matter how absurd.

Thirdly, the fact that MIL vented to your mom was just a result of her being angry. I don't know that you need to address this, but in the future I think that your mother needs to be the bigger person and tell MIL that if she has a problem with you then she should take it up directly with you - and leave it at that. No reason for MIL vs. MIL.

Obviously this is JMO but I would say to remember to keep calm and matter of fact about things when speaking to MIL. Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window