Re: So it's been a while.....what's the consensus on Hylands teething tablets?
Posted 6/3/2011 10:23:12 PM by wingsofsong


Posted by mommyIam


Posted by wingsofsong


Posted by DSLaff

from my ped

I do not recommend Humphreys at ALL!!! It contains belladonna which is a known neuro- toxin. I have included info about what I like to do for teething. ...

WE DO NOT RECOMMEND BABY ORAJEL OR ANBESOL. WE DO NOT RECOMMEND HYLAND’S or HUMPHREY’S TEETHING TABLETS OR TEETHING GEL.




Our ped feels similarly, although didn't go into as much detail about what she DOES recommend. She definitely specified that Orajel, Anbesol, any gels, and teething tablets, drops, etc. are not safe to use. She recommends good old fashioned teethers, and a dose or 2 of Tylenol for the really rough times.



I would question your ped if they understand what the processing of these homeopathic teething tablets and how much belladonna is actually in it.

MY DH is a physican and said exactly what your peds are saying. He's young and goes by the book. Has no idea about anything outside the book. I think he's a good doctor, but has a lot to learn.

My ped on the other hand, comes from a family of peds. He's teaches at university, extreemly reputable, and has a working scientific understanding of homeopathic medicine. He says there is no harm, but don't expect any benefit.

Anyone who thinks there is any harm from these teething tablets is ignorant of what they actually are and that alone for a doctor is a good reason to say they aren't safe. I'm not saying your peds aren't knowledgeable, I'm just saying I feel like so many physicians don't have enough respect for alternative medicine to even bother understanding it. Its not taught at med school. And if you think that's okay, I was diagnosed with a debilitating disorder when I was prego, that is not taught in med school. I had to be diagnosed by a phsycial therapist who essentially cured me. Its weird complicated politics of profit that keeps doctors from learning what could help people, even when it wont save anyone's life. I remind my DH of this all the time. The end result shouldn't always be to save someone's life, but to give them a better quality of life, and that is not taught in med school unless it goes under the title of elective procedures for huge profits.

Not trying to start drama, just food for thought.



Our ped is definitely aware of alternative and nontraditional treatments, and has recommended some for other things in the past. The problem with things like Hyland's tablets, etc. is that they are not regulated by the FDA, so there is no true "authority" keeping them in check and verifying that what they are asserting is true and that their product is 100% safe. That is the concern with products like that. It would not have been recalled if it was 100% undeniably safe.
Print Post      Close Window