I feel bad... did I do the right thing?
Posted 5/14/2011 7:45:02 PM by Bxgell2

Alex was hanging out with our neighbor today. She has three daughters - Abigail who is 6, Natalie who is 9 and Jasmine, who is 12.

The girls have some behavioral issues - most of it is because this is the neighbor who divorced her husband a few years ago because he is a drug addict. She is raising the three girls on her own, on a secretary salary. She's trying her best, but she's not all that attentive to the girls, and doesn't really discipline them. Their father is completely out of the picture, and the mother, while I tolerate her, is just a whackadoodle at times, and it really affects the girls.

The youngest, abigail, is really close with Alex. But she's starting to have SERIOUS behavioral issues. The mom has been called into school several times. I know that many will question why I allow Alex to spend so much time with her, but I think it's important that Alex be exposed to kids of different backgrounds, and anytime there is a problem, I walk her through it. I want her to be compassionate, and understanding and accepting of different types of people.

So, anyway, Alex and Abigail often fight like sisters because they spend so much time together. But, today, Alex came home hysterically sobbing. Apparently she and Abigail got into a fight, and Abigail started punching Alex in the head, and kicked her in the stomach. I tweezed out of her what really happened - they were fighting over stickers, Abigail wanted Alex to put a sticker in one place, Alex refused and put it somehwhere else, so Abigail punched Alex. Alex spit on Abigail, so Abigail kicked her in the stomach, and then Alex fought back by hitting Abigail.

I'm not one of those "my kid is an angel" types - I know that, to some degree, Alex probably instigated the fight. But, I also know Abigail and this does not come as much of a surprise.

Alex was extremely upset, and sobbing, so we spent some time just hugging and talking about what happened. I told her that what Abigail did was wrong, and that we NEVER hit. It's OK to be angry, but we use our words, not our hands. And then we talked about what Alex did wrong too. We talked about how Alex spit on Abigail and hit her because she was angry and frustrated, and how the right thing to do is to tell a grownup, walk away or yell NO.

So, on one hand, I feel so bad for my little girl that she was punched and kicked, and I want to give her all the support and cushioning she needs. On another hand, I want Alex to understand her role in these kind of fights. So, although I told her she could watch a movie tonight, I didn't allow her the movie. She said she understood it was because she spit and hit Abigail. And she also went to bed with no books.

I told her that, if she is good tomorrow, she'll get her movie.

What do you think? Too harsh? Should I have just focused on Abigail's actions and not discipline Alex for her role? Should I have supported her in defending herself?

I haven't talked yet with the Mom. I didn't want to go over there angry or accusatory so I'm going to wait until tomorrow to talk to her about the situation.
Print Post      Close Window