Re: American Idol - Final Four- 5/11
Posted 5/12/2011 12:27:11 PM by KittyGags
Posted by shiv
Posted by SecretTTCer
I am so surprised you all hate Haley. Her voice is unbelievable. She has incredible talent. Didn't you think that second song was amazing?
I agree this is like an anti-Haley thread. She's AMAZING and it pis ses me off that the judges always go after her. She got upset up there but that was because they just kept repeating the same thing and well when the judges critic someone that is usually the person to go home! So I get why she would get upset. I thought both of her songs were great and she didn't deserve the critisicm they gave her.
Scotty sang that 9-11 song that I just can't stand- the guy who originally sang it capitalized off the horrible events of that day and made a ton of money. I thought he second song was cheesy. But I do like Scotty- he'll be sooo successul after this even if he doesn't win. I think he'll be in the finals.
I never liked James, he's so fake. He did good with the journey song but I'm just not a fan- ugh.
Lauren did good on the first, not so great the second.
It's going to be tough- I really hope Haley stays!!!
ITA with all of this!!!!!!!!
|