Re: American Idol - Final Four- 5/11
Posted 5/11/2011 9:52:36 PM by BaysideForever


Posted by KellyFG

I think the judges were too hard on her with the first song and she is very unique. None of the other contestants are as unique as her. My DH loves her, I think she's relying on the middleaged man vote now LOL, my husband watched religiously but would never vote.



Chat Icon Chat Icon

Yeah, my DH says her looks are what have gotten her through.

Yes, she has an unbelievable and unique voice but as everyone knows, Idol isn't solely about that. You also have to know how to cater towards your voice and special qualities and I don't feel she does that. Her first song was terrible. It really was. She doesn't always pick the right songs or correct arrangements. She has been very inconsistent and I don't like her entertainment quality. Sure, I'd listen to a CD with her voice on it but I don't want to have to see her on TV or watch her perform or do an interview. And there have been other unique contestants on Idol in previous seasons. Just because you are unique doesn't mean you should win.
Print Post      Close Window