Re: American Idol- 5/4- Top 5!
Posted 5/5/2011 10:33:06 AM by eroxgirl

Haley..first song, blech. Second song, AMAZING. I wish I liked her personality (which she has none of) because I think she is terrific. I love her sound but she just has a nasty personality.



James - first song was okay, second song he got everyone with his emotion but technically it wasn't good. But he's great and I think we all know this. I love his heart.

Jacob - I'll just quote my girl Noreen here


Posted by nycchic24

Jacob..GO HOME GO HOME GO HOME! *** WAS THAT TONIGHT???????????? WHO IS VOTING FOR HIM???????????

GOODBYE JACOB!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



Lauren - FANTASTIC on the first song and looked gorgeous to boot! For the second song, well, at least she looked nice. She killed it and not in a good way.

Scotty - I like this kid despite myself. First song really good; second song I still liked him.

Haley - WHY does everyone get so down on this girl!>! I think people totally misread her personality. I didn't think she was name dropping at all - she was singing an unreleased song (admittedly a big mistake) and I thought she was being humble since she's no Lady Gaga. I thought when she was criticized at the end she was crushed and that she was showing regret. But that's just me. And she NAILED House of the Rising Sun.

Print Post      Close Window