|
Re: American Idol- 5/4- Top 5!
Posted 5/5/2011 10:33:06 AM by eroxgirl Haley..first song, blech. Second song, AMAZING. I wish I liked her personality (which she has none of) because I think she is terrific. I love her sound but she just has a nasty personality. James - first song was okay, second song he got everyone with his emotion but technically it wasn't good. But he's great and I think we all know this. I love his heart. Jacob - I'll just quote my girl Noreen here
Lauren - FANTASTIC on the first song and looked gorgeous to boot! For the second song, well, at least she looked nice. She killed it and not in a good way. Scotty - I like this kid despite myself. First song really good; second song I still liked him. Haley - WHY does everyone get so down on this girl!>! I think people totally misread her personality. I didn't think she was name dropping at all - she was singing an unreleased song (admittedly a big mistake) and I thought she was being humble since she's no Lady Gaga. I thought when she was criticized at the end she was crushed and that she was showing regret. But that's just me. And she NAILED House of the Rising Sun. |