Re: American Idol- 5/4- Top 5!
Posted 5/5/2011 7:27:04 AM by BaysideForever

OK so yesterday I was only able to watch the first three performances. So I just wanted to add comments now that I am watching the rest

-Scotty's first performance was great and he wasn't even holding the microphone all annoying. it was totally different for him and I loved it.

-Haley's first song was awful. She sounded like she was screaming and screeching especially during the end. It just gave me headache... and it was soooo annoying how she had to "name drop" and say that she wasn't going to do the song until she talked to lady gaga and then promptly bragged that she spoke with her on the phone. And after the song when she was talking to Ryan she looked like she was on drugs. She was making such weird faces and it was like her eyelids were too heavy for her to keep open.

Jacob needs to go home, I know that... but I really can't deal with her anymore.

-James. i know there are a ton of fans of his on here... but I have never really liked him... I wanted him to just nail that second song because it was a good choice but he was so off and all over the place. It was emotional so that was good but if you listen to the live track without watching, it is pretty awful. Randy really hit it head on saying that it wasn't good vocally but he has the personality and emotion to get people attached to him.

And for the people commenting on J-Lo's look... I didn't think it was the worst we've seen this season but her hair did look like a birds nest!
Print Post      Close Window