Re: NYC Teaching Fellows - Has anyone applied or have feedback?
Posted 4/12/2011 10:47:58 AM by jax1


Posted by SweetestThing

I'm sorry, but I've never met more miserable people in my life than Teaching Fellows. And I've known several.

They throw you into the worst schools imaginable (like the school I taught at for 6 years, where I met two) and make you get your Master's in - what, a year? So it's your first year teaching and you're overwhelmed, stressed, and miserable. You have to take Master's-level courses at night and on weekends so you don't have one minute to decompress or chill out. And you're in the toughest schools so your job is that much harder. I taught at a school like that, and I lasted for 6 years. But I wasn't enrolled in an accelerated Master's program at the time.

The people who volunteer for this are generally wonderful - selfless, motivated, very intelligent individuals. This program chews them up and spits them out. My best friend did a similar program in another city (Teach for America) and she lasted 10 weeks. The people I went to grad school with who were in the program would go home sobbing a few times a week. It was awful. I'm sorry I don't have better things to say about the program, but this has been my experience with it.



As a former fellow, I totally disagree! You get your MA in 2 years. You go to school in the summer, and you take 1 or 2 classes each semester. It honestly wasn't that bad of a schedule IMO. Yes, your first year is hard, but that is for any teacher. By my second year, I was fine, and by my third year after my MA, I felt like a confident, competent math teacher.

Most of the people in my cohort excelled and are still teaching (5 years later). Yes, a few dropped out a long the way, but that is the same with people who get into education the traditional way; teaching in the city is TOUGH These schools need a lot of improvement.

Anyway, as a Fellow, you apply to any school. Yes, it should be high needs, but you can apply to any school in whatever borough you are assigned. So it's not like they place you in the worst school. They used to place you, but it changed a while ago, and you do the placement on your own.

This post just rubbed me the wrong way. Most people had a great experience as a Fellow, and working with Fellows. My old school was almost all Fellows and everyone was doing really well.
Print Post      Close Window